View Full Version : Niners and Chargers TRADE Looms...
nabona9erfann
03-09-2005, 10:39 AM
I have been hearing it all over the radio stations in the BAY area.
The Niners and Chargers are in Serious negotiations and one of two option will possibly be taking place, this is what they are suppose to be sorting out now.
Option # 1) The Niners send their 1st pick overall and Julian Peterson to the Chargers for the Chargers two 1st round picks ( # 12 and # 28 ) and Drew Brees.
Option #2) The Niners send their 1st pick overall to the Chargers for their # 12th pick and Philip Rivers.
They are also stating that the reason the Chargers are wanting to do the trade so badly is because they want BRAYLON EDWARDS from Michigan.
The NFL's first 2005 Draft trade is upon us!!
This has been going around. As a 9er fan I rather have Option one, but I rather not do the trade at all and just pick Braylon Edwards areselfs...
2ANGELES7
03-09-2005, 10:42 AM
Which radio stations have been saying this?
GO SAN DIEGO SUPERCHARGERS!!!
reboltfan
03-09-2005, 10:46 AM
Sorry. Just don't buy it...especially option #2. The Chargers should receive a top 10 pick for Rivers alone. He was basically a top five pick and now has some experience (in theory more value). I could believe a rumor that the Chargers were trading PR for the 49rs #1 but AJ said the Chargers had no plans on trading PR at this time so IMHO only an incredible offer that he can't turn down would make him go back on his word.
The 49r fans should be dreaming about this. Either one of these options would be lopsided in their favor and just don't make sense for the Chargers.
One more thing...on option #1 (which also won't happen)...how about the 49rs #1 and Julian Peterson for Drew Brees and the Chargers #28. Again, it won't happen because DB will start for the Chargers this year, but its more realistic. Chargers can get a strong OLB in the draft at #28.
BeWaReDaBoLt
03-09-2005, 10:46 AM
i live in the bay i dont hear nothing about the niners and the chargers trading....and why would we trade 2 first rounders plus drew brees for one first rounder and julian peterson....option to would be more logical if any....plus it states in some articles that the niners are trying so hard to trade the number 1 pick but nobody wants it...ill find the link...i forgot where i read that
BeWaReDaBoLt
03-09-2005, 10:51 AM
LINK (http://msn.foxsports.com/nfl/story/3436126)
i found it...
The 49ers are desperate to trade down to address their many needs, but no other team wants this pick. Rodgers is a nice prospect but not a no-brainer No. 1 overall pick. He has terrific arm strength and good accuracy and would be an instant upgrade over Tim Rattay or Ken Dorsey.
smlman2
03-09-2005, 10:53 AM
hmmm. i dont know.maybe the phillip one cause i think we're giving them too much inthe first scenerio. and i dont like having the 1st pick this year... too many equal guys to pick from.
Originally posted by: reboltfan
I could believe a rumor that the Chargers were trading PR for the 49rs #1
Rivers is a top 5 pick yes but he was not as #1 nor was he projected to be a #1. So the 49ers would be looney to make a tradde like this. Also I too don't believe any of this trade rumor. It just doesn't make sense.
kcpike11
03-09-2005, 10:57 AM
hmmm sounds like it was posted by a niner fan. I believe there stands a better chance of Fouts coming out of the announcers booth to take over for teh chargers after we trade Brees, LT and Antonio Gates to the Niners for their 2nd round pick and Arnaz Battle
SeauRodneyRules
03-09-2005, 11:12 AM
AJ likes picks. I dont see him giving away 2 picks...NOT IN A MILLION YEARS!
onthegreenrb
03-09-2005, 11:17 AM
Originally posted by: lego
Originally posted by: reboltfan
I could believe a rumor that the Chargers were trading PR for the 49rs #1
Rivers is a top 5 pick yes but he was not as #1 nor was he projected to be a #1. So the 49ers would be looney to make a tradde like this. Also I too don't believe any of this trade rumor. It just doesn't make sense.
Rivers would be considered night and day above the other QBs in this draft. He was essentially a #1 last year and would be a no brainer #1 if he was in this QB class.
maverjoe
03-09-2005, 11:18 AM
Julian Peterson would be awesome.
rule12b
03-09-2005, 11:32 AM
LOL this thread was clearly started by someone on drugs. Not ONE of those scenarios makes a bit of sense. And none of it fits with A.J.'s philosophy. No one wants a #1 pick in this draft since the talent is just NOT that strong. Tossing away a proven vet or a clear #1 (Rivers) for an injured expensive LB (we have plenty) and Braylon Edwards?!? Put the crack pipe down.
eeks2284
03-09-2005, 11:39 AM
the radio personality which produced this rumor was one lee quacksaw hamilton.. that should tell you enough
yodafro
03-09-2005, 11:48 AM
Not going to happen. The Chargers will be using both of their 1st round picks.
foty89
03-09-2005, 11:50 AM
Considering what A.J. has said, the only deal I could see happening is Drew for the first pick AND Peterson. Or some other deal involving players. There is no way the Chargers would give up both of their first rounders for only one. The top pick is just not worth it this year.
Go Bolts!
i/expressions/SDG_Bolt.gif i/expressions/SDG_Bolt.gif i/expressions/SDG_Bolt.gif
TBOLTZCALI
03-09-2005, 11:50 AM
if we were to offer PR and our 28th, i can almost say they would bite in it. PR, even though not a proven NFL QB has alot more skillz than the QB's out of this years draft. Plus a 28th pick. Sounds more to me that we aren't getting the best end here.
Thunderstruck
03-09-2005, 11:53 AM
I would think that they'd take PR straight up for the #1 pick. He's better than any QB in the draft right now, he's already under contract so he won't hold out, and he's got a year in an NFL system under his belt.
They'd need to offer their 1 and their 3 for PR.
kiwibolt
03-09-2005, 12:09 PM
If that was really on the radio then those radio guys need a drug test.
both #1 picks and Drew Brees for Peterson and the #1 pick this year? Why in the world would we do that? Does Peterson even fit our 3-4 scheme?!! He's a great LB, but we need DE help. Plus, why don't we just hope DJ falls to 12 or pick Merriman at 12, fill our supposed need at LB and then keep our #1 picks and Brees?
or
SF's #1 for our #1 plus PR? PR is a better prospect than any QB in the draft this year. Why would AJ give up PR (with a years experience) AND our #1 this year so that we could draft 11 spots higher?
Crack kills....i/expressions/face-icon-small-confused.gif
chargersfan5521
03-09-2005, 12:11 PM
Originally posted by: nabona9erfann
I have been hearing it all over the radio stations in the BAY area.
The Niners and Chargers are in Serious negotiations and one of two option will possibly be taking place, this is what they are suppose to be sorting out now.
Option # 1) The Niners send their 1st pick overall and Julian Peterson to the Chargers for the Chargers two 1st round picks ( # 12 and # 28 ) and Drew Brees.
Option #2) The Niners send their 1st pick overall to the Chargers for their # 12th pick and Philip Rivers.
They are also stating that the reason the Chargers are wanting to do the trade so badly is because they want BRAYLON EDWARDS from Michigan.
The NFL's first 2005 Draft trade is upon us!!
This has been going around. As a 9er fan I rather have Option one, but I rather not do the trade at all and just pick Braylon Edwards areselfs...
i think your hearing things
Boltbacker
03-09-2005, 12:14 PM
There is not a chance we would do this, there is no clear cut 1st pick this year let alone us giving up both of our #1's and Drew Brees also. I just dont see this happening.
Sogvet17
03-09-2005, 12:39 PM
I think this is one of the better laughs I've had on these forums. First, Edwards is not worthy of the #1 pick and will be a real pain to sign if selected there. Second, there is no scenario where AJ will give up PR for anything short of a couple of first round picks; say, SF's 1st this year and their 1st next year. That way we would probably be picking 1 0r 2 next year and could line up for one of the quality QB's or OT coming out. Third, does SF have the room under the cap to sign DB to a long term contract, which he will require and/or absorb the huge hit that PR will do to the cap. Fourth...........if this was indeed hacksaw, then you know first hand it is BS.................IMHO
Meek858
03-09-2005, 01:07 PM
How Reliable is This post? Is this just some BS you pulled out of your @ss or is this ligitiment?
happygilmor987
03-09-2005, 01:45 PM
im calling BS on this
BOLTERFAN
03-09-2005, 01:56 PM
Originally posted by: nabona9erfann
I have been hearing it all over the radio stations in the BAY area.
The Niners and Chargers are in Serious negotiations and one of two option will possibly be taking place, this is what they are suppose to be sorting out now.
Option # 1) The Niners send their 1st pick overall and Julian Peterson to the Chargers for the Chargers two 1st round picks ( # 12 and # 28 ) and Drew Brees.
Option #2) The Niners send their 1st pick overall to the Chargers for their # 12th pick and Philip Rivers.
They are also stating that the reason the Chargers are wanting to do the trade so badly is because they want BRAYLON EDWARDS from Michigan.
The NFL's first 2005 Draft trade is upon us!!
This has been going around. As a 9er fan I rather have Option one, but I rather not do the trade at all and just pick Braylon Edwards areselfs...
Not gonna happen ever. AJ dictates the price in ANY deal the bolts make. That is such a bad trade.
conair103
03-09-2005, 04:00 PM
theres been 2 threads of this.......maybe its not so fake i/expressions/SDG_Football.gifi/expressions/face-icon-small-frown.gifi/expressions/present.gifi/expressions/heart.gifi/expressions/SDG_Helmet.gif
edh22
03-09-2005, 04:24 PM
Breaking news! Safety Jerry Wilson traded to the 49ers for some smokes and a case of gatorade.....has about the same chance of happening (altho not a bad idea)
JoeMcRugby
03-09-2005, 04:26 PM
Originally posted by: conair103
theres been 2 threads of this.......maybe its not so fake
Two threads started by two brand new posters trolling through the board.
sanluischargerfan
03-09-2005, 04:32 PM
Originally posted by: nabona9erfann
I have been hearing it all over the radio stations in the BAY area.
The Niners and Chargers are in Serious negotiations and one of two option will possibly be taking place, this is what they are suppose to be sorting out now.
Option # 1) The Niners send their 1st pick overall and Julian Peterson to the Chargers for the Chargers two 1st round picks ( # 12 and # 28 ) and Drew Brees.
Option #2) The Niners send their 1st pick overall to the Chargers for their # 12th pick and Philip Rivers.
They are also stating that the reason the Chargers are wanting to do the trade so badly is because they want BRAYLON EDWARDS from Michigan.
The NFL's first 2005 Draft trade is upon us!!
This has been going around. As a 9er fan I rather have Option one, but I rather not do the trade at all and just pick Braylon Edwards areselfs...
====================================
I don't think this is going to happen.
Must be Radio personality trying to boost his ratings.
regman911
03-09-2005, 05:27 PM
The rumour is Brees plus both first round picks to S.F. for Peterson and the #1 pick. They have been saying it on espn radio in Nor Cal citing sports blogospheres as the source of the leak. I am a Niner fan and ANY QB would be an upgrade for us! I think this is total B.S. as the charger front office cant be that stupid. Peterson is our best player but he tore his achilles early last season and it is not even known if he has fully recovered, so consequently he may not be the same player he has been in the past. As far as PR is concerned, no one can say he is any different then Smith or Rodgers as none of these guys have started a game in the NFL, one year on the bench does not gaurantee anything either way. The Chargers should stay with DB as he is a proven winner, the Niners will be stuck with the #1 pick (They will Pick Rodgers). Peterson has been franchised the last 2 years and already turned down a multi year deal that would have made him the third highest paid LB behind arrington and lewis. SO he will probably split S.F. when they stop franchising him. The other thing included in the trade rumour stipulated that the Niners coach stated that if the supposed trade info were leaked to the media the deal would be off. That alone would indicate the fabrication of the story!
chargertom
03-10-2005, 07:36 PM
Originally posted by: nabona9erfann
I have been hearing it all over the radio stations in the BAY area.
The Niners and Chargers are in Serious negotiations and one of two option will possibly be taking place, this is what they are suppose to be sorting out now.
Option # 1) The Niners send their 1st pick overall and Julian Peterson to the Chargers for the Chargers two 1st round picks ( # 12 and # 28 ) and Drew Brees.
Option #2) The Niners send their 1st pick overall to the Chargers for their # 12th pick and Philip Rivers.
They are also stating that the reason the Chargers are wanting to do the trade so badly is because they want BRAYLON EDWARDS from Michigan. The NFL's first 2005 Draft trade is upon us!!
This has been going around. As a 9er fan I rather have Option one, but I rather not do the trade at all and just pick Braylon Edwards areselfs...
Call the doctor, and have him reduce the dosage. Sit quietly, and wait for help to arrive.
Go Chargers!